Good budgets are informed by evidence and based on needs

  • The current special education funding model relies on out-dated census data to make predictions about our students. We must base funding on the needs of our currently enrolled students. 

  • Local communities and students do not fit into modelling based on 2006 and 2021 census data. To cover the widening gap between old data and real life, money is shuffled inefficiently from budget line to budget line. 

  • Students’ needs are well-documented by families, healthcare workers, and educators but these needs are not properly tracked or documented centrally by the OCDSB. 

  • To meet the needs of our students we must first know what those needs are. To measure the efficacy of our policies and programs, we must collect data on the availability and denial of learning supports.

Underfunded by a broken funding model

Our school board is underfunded and has been for decades. 

The budget shortfall comes from decades of chronic underfunding of school boards across the province. In the late 1990s, when I was attending Fisher Park middle school, the province imposed a one-size-fits-all funding model onto every school board. The OCDSB was forced to make deep cuts to programs and close schools in order to align with the Harris government’s reduction in funding. Despite changes in governments, investments in kindergarten programs, and tweaks to the funding model, many cuts continued and the original Harris government cuts were never reversed.*

I see two problems with our current funding model:

One, the funding model does not provide enough money to pay for the education workers and supplies that our students need. We need more funding from the province, and that is going to take organized and sustained advocacy (I’ll be writing more on advocacy in the coming days).

Two, special education funding depends, in large part, on a 20-year-old prediction, not an assessment of what our current students need. 

What happens when funding does not match our needs? 

When students need more learning support than predicted, one of two things happen: funds are moved from another budget line or a deficit is created to meet student needs.**

Borrowing money from one line to another is a practice that tells us that the funding is too low. Moving money from one allocation to another masks the shortfall for a year or two. It can lead to financial mismanagement if funds allocated to one program have never been spent appropriately. According to the Auditor General of Ontario (2017), that seems to be a common practice across the province. 

The province has given the OCDSB and all other school boards inadequate funding with no flexibility. Our yearly budgets rely  on moving money around so that some of the highest needs students might receive some help. 

Creating a deficit to meet student needs is the other option but deficits create the condition for school boards to be taken over by the Minister of Education, removing local voices, as has been done to the OCDSB. When trustees have refused to make cuts to balance the budget, the Ministry has intervened to make those cuts, against the wishes of the school communities and those elected to represent them. 

Why don’t we have a needs-based funding model?

In 2010, the Province changed special education funding from needs-based to statistical modelling that predicts disabilities based on the 2006 StatsCan census data. This model was updated in 2023 but instead of using the most up-to-date census data, they brought in 2020 census data weighted at only 20%.

It makes no sense that our current funding model for special education is a formula where 20 year old data vastly outweighs 6 year old data! Making it even more infuriating, the 2020 data does not capture the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic nor does it reflect our current housing and food affordability crises.

This wildly out-of-date formula is used to make predictions about the current needs of the very real children living in our communities. We do not need to rely on 2006 or 2020 census data to make predictions about the kids in our communities whose families and educators have, in most cases, extensively documented their needs!

The OCDSB is an example of what happens when we run out of ways to compensate for this abject failure of the provincial funding model. When underfunding is hidden behind outdated predictive statistical models, we stop collecting current data. Then we move money from budget line to budget line. Then, it becomes easy to blame the management of the budget rather than the funding model itself. At every single point in this broken process, the students’ needs are not prioritized.

What am I going to do about it?

Making evidence-based policies based on the current needs of our students goes hand-in-hand with our right to high quality public education. Our school boards are meant to be locally governed so that learning needs across diverse communities can be met. We cannot meet this basic democratic principle without good data, or democratically elected trustees!

We must immediately create a policy to collect up-to-date, comparable data on our students’ needs and the gaps that currently exist in our programs.

If the supervisor, OCDSB leadership team, and the Ministry of Education (MoE) are truly serious about “putting students first”, they must invest in robust data collection so that we know what students need and how many students are being denied supports. If the OCDSB and the MoE is committed to prudent fiscal management, they must ensure that our budget is designed around our students’ needs first. We have to be able to measure how our budgets and policies meet, or fail, our students’ needs.

Transparent, accountable, and responsible governance is impossible without good data.

Sound fiscal management is impossible without good data.

- Emily.

*For more information about the funding model the effects on school board budgets, please see reports by: Auditor General of Ontario (2017) and (2026), Mitchell Beer (2002), Elementary Teachers Federation of Ontario (2017) and (2025), Financial Accountability Office of Ontario (2025) and (2026), and Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (2018) and (2026).

**The third option is to deny students what they need, in the form of multi-yearlong waitlists or cancellation of programs.

Visit my Instagram to watch my reel and share with your network!